‏إظهار الرسائل ذات التسميات English. إظهار كافة الرسائل
‏إظهار الرسائل ذات التسميات English. إظهار كافة الرسائل

RAW manages blast in Jalalabad to destabilize Pak-Afghan ties’

 Mian Saifur Rehman
The latest Jalalabad suicide bomb blast is the handiwork of RAW and its associates and operatives and it was timed in such a manner to take place at the time when the passing out parade was scheduled at Kakul Academy in Pakistan with the participation of Afghan Army chief as the parade’s chief guest.
 According to Pakistan’s highly authentic defence sources, as Indian intelligence agencies have intensified their destabilizing efforts in the region, Pakistan’s intelligence network has enhanced its surveillance capability that has enabled it to unearth RAW linkages behind Jalalabad suicide attack. This attack was conducted in Afghanistan’s eastern city of Jalalabad, killing 33 people and injuring more than 100 outside a bank where government workers collect salaries.
 According to reliable Pakistani sources in the security establishment, the only objective of carrying out this “timed (or well-timed)” suicide attack was to sabotage the growing Pak-Afghan collaboration in the area of securing the region as well as in the area of combating terrorism.
When asked whether this information about RAW’s involvement was an inference drawn from the Indian agency’s track record or otherwise, the Pakistani defence sources told The News that they (Pak intelligence) carried out intensive research into the happening that was investigated in the light of substantial evidence connecting RAW and its operatives and supporters with the tragic occurrence of Jalalabad.
 It was also revealed on this occasion that RAW intends to activate its operatives to carry out more attacks of varied nature.
 The sole purpose, according to sources, was to “avenge” the growing nearness between Pakistan and Afghanistan and to create an atmosphere of widespread insecurity by way of destabilising the region.

Intra Afghan talks

K. Iqbal
Afghan government and the Taliban are poised to hold face-to-face talks following the behind the scenes encouragement by Pakistan, America and other stakeholders. The two sides—Taliban and Afghan government have been in informal contact with each other for some time. However, this is the first time that they plan to publicly share a table to converse about the future political landscape of Afghanistan. Committees for proposed talks on both the sides are engaged in affairs like discussing agendas for talks and other issues. However, as of now, no direct meeting has taken place.

America is encouraging Pakistan and China to support President Ghani’s reconciliation efforts. President Obama’s special envoy, Daniel F Feldman, has visited Islamabad and held important talks. He met Army Chief General Raheel Sharif as well. The regional situation was discussed during these meetings. Feldman appreciated Pakistan’s positive role for peace and stability in Afghanistan. Feldman’s visit was aimed at discussing the prospects of a peace deal in the backdrop of the latest initiatives. Afghan Taliban talks with the government in Kabul are likely to take place soon, though certain sticky issues are yet to be finalized; for example, Islamabad, Beijing, Kabul and Dubai have been short listed as possible venues; however, efforts are being made to arrange the talks in Kabul in an effort to show that the process is Afghan-led and Afghan-owned.

President Obama held a video conference with President Ashraf Ghani, on March 13, and discussed the peace process and commended the regime’s efforts to improve relationship with Pakistan. Afghanistan’s Chief Executive Officer Dr Abdullah Abdullah also participated in the conference call.
Debate is ongoing on the issue of the presence of foreign forces in Afghanistan; spokesman for Afghan Taliban Zabihullah Mujahid has commented in a message that no doubt that Afghans want peace, but this is possible after the foreign forces stop aggression and allow sovereignty to Afghans. The Taliban leadership is not out-rightly rejecting the prospect of talks with the Afghan government. China’s foreign minister last month said during a visit to Islamabad that Beijing was willing to help mediate talks to end the Afghan war.

Reportedly, China has held rounds of talks with the Taliban and asked them to hold direct talks with the Afghan government. The Chinese have held “one, two or three” rounds of talks with the Taliban in the past few months, Dr Abdullah Abdullah said at a conference organized by an Indian media group. Abdullah, speaking at the India Today Conclave 2015 in New Delhi, did not say where the meetings took place. Abdullah’s backing of the nascent process is crucial because many of his supporters represent the anti-Taliban sentiment.

The Taliban side is silent over the Afghan government’s willingness to give share to them in power and also accept their demands within the constitutional framework. Taliban are accepting that their members visit certain countries for various issues and have traditional links with several countries. An Afghan government official has said that the issues about which Taliban have concerns could be discussed and sorted out once the talk process starts. The next few days are very crucial. It is a make-or-break situation. All sides are very much aware of the fact that the breakthrough has to be achieved before the Taliban’s spring offensive. All stakeholders are pushing for a formal ceasefire in order to pave the way for meaningful talks before the Afghan Taliban begin their spring offensive in May. The first round of talks will focus on striking a deal on a ceasefire. China is to act as a ‘guarantor’ for any peace deal between the insurgents and the Afghan government. Pakistan and Afghanistan have agreed to set up a joint committee to work out a mechanism for documentation of unregistered Afghan nationals in Pakistan.

While talking to Afghan Minister for Refugees and Repatriation, Sayed Balkhi, Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif has said that building stable and cooperative relations with all countries of the region including Afghanistan is part of his vision for a peaceful neighborhood, adding that Pakistan is fully committed to the internationally endorsed Solution Strategy for Afghan Refugees. During the London Conference on Afghanistan, in December 2014, Prime Minister Nawaz called upon the international community to support Afghanistan to bring back Afghan refugees living abroad, by helping to create conducive conditions for sustainable reintegration into their homeland. Pakistan respects the principle of voluntary return and feels encouraged that the Afghan government is creating pull factors to incentives the return of refugees. Balkhi said an inter-ministerial Board has been formed in Afghanistan for overseeing the return of Afghan refugees which is being chaired by President Ashraf Ghani. Balkhi said it is the desire of the Afghan people to focus on economic development and not to hear the sound of gunshots again.

With the change of leadership in Afghanistan, the two countries have commenced a historic new phase in bilateral relations. Now, focus is on enhanced political engagement, security and counter-terrorism cooperation, trade and economic partnership, and regional cooperation. Terrorism is a common enemy of the two countries and it requires common endeavors to defeat it. Both the countries have paid a very heavy price at the hands of terrorism and now Pakistan has launched Operation Zarb-e-Azb which has broken the backbone of the terrorist network in the country. Pakistan has a commitment not to allow its territories to be used against other countries. Pakistan is in favor of an Afghan-owned and Afghan-led peace and reconciliation process.

Both sides—Taliban and the Afghan government—are deeply suspicious of each other. Taliban representatives have indicated that should talks begin, they would make demands including the immediate departure of all foreign troops. A senior aide to Ghani said anticipated Taliban demands, which may also include re-imposing the harsh interpretation of Islamic law would be unacceptable. The aide said Pakistani intermediaries were “working to find middle ground”, but so far reported no change in the Taliban stance. “If these demands are not softened,” the aide said, “the first day of talks could become the last day of talks.”

Prime Minister’s Adviser on National Security and Foreign Affairs Sartaj Aziz has also confirmed that the Afghan government and the Taliban were preparing to hold negotiations. Pakistan has always supported such a process, and re-emphasized it to be transparent, Afghan-owned and Afghan-led.

The process of intra-Afghan negotiations is likely to be painstakingly slow, and progress could be akin to one step forward and two backwards. At this critical time, caution is due for Pakistan that it should not get involved in the internal affairs of Afghanistan. Even if officially invited by the Afghan government, it should only facilitate the process to the extent requested by the Afghan government and Taliban.

The interlocutors of the Afghan peace and reconciliation process should look for strong guarantors to the anticipated agreement. No single country could bear such a burden; however it would be appropriate if all permanent members of UNSC and all six immediate neighbors of Afghanistan jointly underwrite the forthcoming political arrangement in Afghanistan. Above all, America, the real power yielder in Afghanistan owes it to the Afghan people and the international community to make the process of intra-Afghan negotiations a success.

ANSWERING FROM OTHER SIDE OF THE FENCE

Gulshan Rafique
In a recent interview to Nidhi Razdan on NDTV, Hussain Haqqani, a former diplomat has raised some questions pertaining to the intentions of Pakistan to fight terrorism and eliminate militancy. His doubts corroborated the views of his Indian interviewer but were largely ignorant of the current scenario. In the wake of the Peshawar massacre of 144 school children on December 16, 2014 the government’s response has come out in the form of the 20-point National Action Plan (NAP) and according to some media sources more than 600 terrorists have been arrested since the approval of the NAP . The response by the government is widely considered as natural, demanding corrective and punitive action. Some of the major steps taken by the government are as follows:
The NAP not only promises establishment of special trial courts for two years for speedy trial of terror suspects but it also chokes financing for terrorists and terrorist organisations, and ensures against re-emergence of proscribed organizations. A serious battle against various militant groups has started with the launch of a military operation called the Zarb-i-Azb in North Waziristan. Pakistan army is making sure that the area does not again become a sanctuary for jihadi groups. Besides Operation Zarb-i-Azb, Operation Khyber -1, Operation Khyber – 2 and ongoing Rangers’ Operations in Karachi are being conducted as a consequence of NAP.
Moreover, the government is also taking steps to develop a national discourse which Mr. Haqqani has claimed to be missing in his interview and a positive narrative to stand together against terrorism and militancy is continuously building up. The number of banned terrorist outfits has reached to seventy-two and a national consensus is being reached against militant outfits of all hue and color. In this regard, the protests of civil society against the statement of a religious cleric, Maulvi Abdul Aziz, in Islamabad made him apologies for his comments. This shows that the government and the society have joined hands in the fight against extremism. Lashkar-Taiba is banned in Pakistan. Jamaat-ud-Dawa (JuD) is a charitable and not terrorist organization but the bank accounts of JuD have also been frozen and foreign travel restrictions have been imposed on Hafiz Saeed by the government of Pakistan. India blames Hafiz Saeed for Mumbai attacks but it did not provide any credible evidence to Pakistani courts for his involvement. So, the governments of Pakistan cannot put him in jail without judicial orders.
Madaris reform is another vital point of NAP. Interior Minister, Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan, has made sure via Ministry of Religious Affairs that 90 per cent madaris have no link to terrorism. Mr. Haqqani also expressed his disapproval to Zakiur Rehman’s bail. It is pertinent to mention that Zakiur Rehman Lakhvi’s hanging case is sub judice. These are legal matters and media trials serve no purpose.
In 2007, at least 50 Pakistanis were killed in Samjhota Express terrorist attacks in India. The investigations and the confession of the mastermind of the attack, Swami Aseemanad, pointed to the involvement of the Indian military officers and some organizations linked to major political parties. When he was granted bail on August 28, 2014, Pakistani government and media did not make an issue out of it unlike their Indian counterparts.
Similarly, a Delhi court recently acquitted 16 Uttar Pradesh police personnel accused in the 1987 Hashimpura massacre, in which more than 40 Muslims were killed in cold blood. The policemen have been set free on account of lack of evidence, and the failure of the state government to establish the identity of the accused policemen. So, again Mr. Haqaani’s criticism of Pakistan’s criminal justice system was slanted and he must have reminded Miss Razdan that those who live in glass houses should not throw stones at others.
He further talked of a change in Pakistan’s approach to Kashmir and suggested that the two countries need to move ahead of Kashmir dispute. Pakistan is always ready to resolve all issues with India, be it the issue of Kashmir, demilitarizing Siachen, Sir Creek, or the water issues of eastern rivers; but it is the Indian side which is always reluctant to talk to Pakistan over these contentious issues.
As for “5000 years of shared history”, there were no Hindu-Muslim riots. Partition is a consequence of majority community’s chauvinism, e.g. in 2002 in the State of Indian Gujarat, as many as 2000 Muslims were massacred and since the last “67 years” Muslims in Kashmir are being brutally suppressed by Indian armed forces. BJP, a single majority party in Indian legislature with 282 seats, does not have a single Muslim member although they constitute about 15% population of India. urthermore, Mr. Haqaani blamed the establishment for influencing the peace process with India, which is not true. It is well-known that the Agra Summit of 2001 that had asked to reduce nuclear arsenal, resolution of all issues including the Kashmir dispute and cross-border terrorism was rejected by Indian military establishment.
In 2013, a retired Indian Army chief General Vijay Kumar Singh admitted that India sponsored bomb blasts in Pakistan and doled out money to the separatist elements for terrorist activities in Balochistan. The current Indian Minister of State for External Affairs was criticized by the Indian extremist elements when he visited the Pakistani High Commissioner in New Dehli on March 23, 2015. Terrorists have no space in Pakistan and there is no difference between “Good” or “Bad” Taliban, especially after the APS attacks. As long as Pakistan is in a state of war against terror, the government cannot live in a state of denial. The whole nation is united and government is fighting for peace in the country against terrorism and extremism without discrimination.

Implementation of NAP

Muhammad Jamil
                      [Implementation of the plan in true letter and spirit is the only way forward to eliminate extremism and terrorism in all its forms and manifestations and establish peace to create climate conducive to INVESTMENT, which will help ensure socio-economic justice in the society. The federal government has taken certain measures; but a lot has yet to be done. The Attorney General\'s office filed reply to the Supreme Court on behalf of the federation in regard to the petitions filed by Lahore High Court Bar Association and others against 21st amendment. While advocate generals of Sindh, Punjab and Balochistan submitted replies on behalf of their respective provincial governments on Monday, the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had submitted its reply already. All the provincial governments supported the amendment and endorsed the points highlighted by the federal government in its reply to the Supreme Court.
It has been stated in the reply that the 21st Amendment did not usurp the judiciary\'s power or put any restrictions, and that the Objective Resolution was not above the law and constitution. It requested the apex court to dismiss the challenges because they had no merit and for the sake of all those who had sacrificed their lives in the war against terrorism, for the sake of children (who died in the Peshawar school attack) and for the sake of the future of the country. The people have spoken through their elected representatives. The federal government and all the four provinces have supported the establishment of military courts for the trial of terrorists in the country. To fight terrorism is indeed a Herculean task, and the nation as a whole will have to participate fully, and the objectives can be achieved by showing firm resolve, patience and hope.
The 21st amendment to the Constitution provided constitutional cover to trial of offences relating to terrorism by military courts, whereas Pakistan Army Act, 1952 was also amended. The Constitution (21st Amendment) Act, 2015 shall remain in force for two years from the date of its commencement, and shall cease to be part of the Constitution and shall stand repealed on the expiration of the period. After 5-hour meeting of parliamentary leaders chaired by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, all leaders reached consensus on all points of National Action Plan including establishment of military courts. Persistent efforts are needed to expose the parties, individuals and madaris having direct or indirect linkage with terrorism, sectarianism and their foreign masters, and take measures to stop their funding. Sri Lanka could decimate Tamil Tigers only when it succeeded in stopping the funding and supply of arms to them.
In All Parties\' Conference, political parties were in complete unison on 20 points National Action Plan (NAP); but now certain political parties disown it on various pretexts and are taking a different stance due to their vested interests. It is strange that after political leaders of the parties had given their consent in the conference of parliamentary leaders convened by the Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, why a few of them stayed away from voting and did not raise dissenting voices? Political division on the issue will certainly take us away from desired goal of eliminating extremism and terrorism from the society, which has immensely harmed the country. Pakistani leadership and the government should demonstrate the resolve, ignore detractors of NAP, show zero tolerance towards anti-state elements and move forward to attain the objectives outlined in the NAP.
Politicians should feel the pulse of the masses and synchronize their aims and objectives in line with the ground realities and reform their political agenda by showing what a change really means and how. Provincial civil administrations have to gird up their loins to fight terrorists in its domain; it should start search operations and identify terrorists as well as those elements that aid and abet them in terror acts. Of course, it would require revamping of CID, special police and other intelligence networks under the civil administration because it is their responsibility to take care of the streets and bazaars of the city. Had civil administrations taken steps, many terrorist attacks could have been averted. Military courts have started functioning; but other points in the NAP are not less important, and should be implemented in letter and spirit.

Action in Inertia

By SM Hali
                        [The National Action Plan (NAP) was evolved in the wake of the carnage at the Army Public School Peshawar on December 16, 20 14, in which nearly 150 people were butchered, including some 132 school children. The initial shock and awe of the brutal massacre galvanized the politicians in uniting for formulating the NAP but pretty soon it became obvious that the unity was short-lived.  In fact, the attempt to present the NAP Bill in the National Assembly had to be abandoned because the ruling party, the PML-N, failed to garner the requisite number of assents as some key allies chose to themselves.  Ultimately, the Bill did make it through after the leader of the House, Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif expressed his displeasure at the dissensions.  Even then the religious parties abstained from the ballot an expose of the peculiarly bent of mind of the orthodoxy!
The proof of the pudding is in the eating.  Once the bill had been approved into law and it was time for implementation, it became evident, as in Shakespeare's Hamlet, that "something is rotten in the state of Denmark".  While the federal government is trying to implement the NAP, the provinces are not too eager about its implementation.  The government's whipping boy, Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan, expressed displeasure over the response of the provincial law enforcement authorities regarding the implementation of NAP and warned them to take the task seriously.  Chairing a high level meeting which reviewed the NAP, Nisar directed the police and officials of other security agencies to adopt a proactive approach on counter-terrorism as the country was in a state of war.  Officials from the National Counter Terrorism Authority (NACTA), the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), the Federal Capital Police, the National Crisis Management Cell and intelligence agencies, along with officials from provincial home departments, attended the meeting.  Although senior officials wanted to give a presentation, they were stopped by the interior minister, who asked them to provide him concrete results over the implementation of NAP, which in turn embarrassed the officials.
It appears that each province has different grounds to harbor reservations.  The Baloch groups are reportedly running their training camps in Afghanistan or Iran.The interior ministry is seeking details about the Balochistan Republican Army, Balochistan Liberation Army, Balochistan Liberation Front, Balochistan Bunyad Parast Army, Lashkar-e-Balochistan, Balochistan Liberation United Front, Balchistan Musallah Defa Tanzeem, Balochistan Waja Liberation Army, Baloch Republican Party Azad, Balochistan United Army and Balochistan National Liberation Army, just to name a few of the organizations reportedly  engaged in anti-state activities. With such a serious insurgency, it is believably difficult to bring a sizable number of provincial politicians on board to support the execution of the NAP.  The province of Sindh, on the other hand, appears to have become a safe haven for terrorist groups.  The military's Operation Zarb-e-Azb in the tribal areas caused terror mongers to seek sanctuaries in other parts of the country.  The  cosmopolitan city of Karachi has the propensity to absorb diverse groups and let them remain incognito owing to its enormous population.  The Sindh Home Department is updating on behavioral changes of Al-Harmain Foundation, Rabita Trust, Tehreek Nifaz-e-Aman, Thafuz hadudullah, Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan and the people's amn Committee.  Despite an across the board operation in the metropolis led the Rangers, so far there is not much to write home about.
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's constraints are divers.  The province, which is in the vicinity of FATA and the Waziristan Agencies – erstwhile home to the harbingers of terror, has a number of sympathizers who will waylay any plan of the government to implement the NAP.  The coalition government of KPK comprises Imran Khan's Tehreek-e-Insaf and the Jammat-e-Islami, both of which are conscientious objectors  to the federal government's plan of action.  additionally, the IS or Daesh has been distributing pamphlets in some parts of the province, inviting recruits. Simultaneously there have been rallies in Peshawar, eulogizing the assailants who targeted the French satire magazine Charlie Hebdo.  With such dichotomy in their approach to terror, it is difficult to comprehend how the NAP will be successful in KPK.  Coming to the most populous province of Punjab, situation differs from the other provinces. It is ruled by Prime Minister Main Niawaz Sharif's younger brother, Shahbaz Sharif, who should prima facie be all out in support of implementing the NAP.  Unfortunately, his reluctance stems from other considerations.  South Punjab is considered a hub of miscreants as most of the militants of the Punjabi Taliban and other jihadi organizations belong to South Punjab.  According to media reports, intelligence agencies found out that SIM card that was in use of the TTP militants during their attack on the Army Public School in Peshawar, belonged to a resident of Hasilpur district of Bahawalpur.  Interior Minister Chandhry Nisar Ali Khan has stated that at last 95 banned outfits were functioning in Punjab.  Nisar declared that law-enforcement agencies were proactively monitoring the madaris to check the spread of terrorist ideology in the country but a government critic has disclosed that despite repeated reminders by the media about the growing militant presence in the  province, the Shahbaz Sharif led Punjab government failed to check the spread of  such outfit and instead preferred to cohabitate with them.
Directives have been issued to the Federal Bureau of Revenue to ensure that funding to proscribed organizations is stopped.  Brotherly Muslim countries have also been asked to clamp down on the financers of sectarian and terrorist networks operating in Pakistan.  It has been recommended to the NAP committee that Iran, Saudi Arabia and the United Emirates should be asked to stop funding the  religious groups banned in Pakistan.  Reportedly, the minister visited Saudi Arabia to request its monarchy to use their good offices to help block the funding of proscribed groups in Pakistan.  There is an obstacle here too. Unfortunately most transactions are carried out through informal means such as Hawala and Hundi for transfer of money, which are difficult to keep a check on.  As far as proscribing terrorist organizations is considered, there is no specific mechanism for banning any outfit. If one head was chopped off, two more cropped up.  As soon as one groups is banned, it resurfaces under a new name.  Around 23 proscribed organizations are functioning with different names – like Jaish-e-Muhammad is operating as Khudam-e-Islam or Al-Rahmat Trust, Lashkar-e-Tayaba as Jamat-ud-Dawa (JUD and so on.  The prime minister has also directed the Ministry of Information Technology to take steps for blocking websites and social media plate forms used by terrorist outfits.  The federal government plans to table its draft cyber security bill in the National Assembly to ensure quick implementation of NAP against terrorism but the draft bill still misses several key areas like online blasphemy, cyber stalking, spamming and spoofing  which are considered serious offences in some other countries. Moreover, the new breed of terrorists is social media savvy and is conversant with the use of proxy servers to bypass firewalls.  In the current milieu, there is every danger of provincial politicians sabotaging the NAP and impeding its efforts towards success.  Such an outcome smacks of jeopardizing the process of democratization, which is still in its nascent stage in Pakistan. 

UN SECURITY COUNCIL'S RESOLUTION 47

Muhammad Faraz
            Kashmir is a nuclear flashpoint, one of the biggest unresolved disputes of the world, major bone of contention between Pakistan and India, the reason for 3 x full scale wars between the two nations, not to forget the countless skirmishes on the border and  according to some experts, a ticking time bomb which might result in a nuclear holocaust. Everyone knows about the above mentioned facts, including the bitter history of  the bitter history of partition of the sub-continent in 1947. The dispute erupted when the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir was forcefully and unjustly annexed to India. Pakistan retaliated and a war was started between the newly born states. know as the “first Kashmir war, Father of the Pakistani Nation Muhammad Ali Jinnah ordered the combined military chief of Pakistan and India, Gen Douglas Gracey, to invade Kashmir but he did not carry out Quaid’s orders, resultantly leaving no option for the tribal people, Kashmir's and some soldiers of Pakistan Army, who were on leave, to march towards Kashmir for its liberation. This indigenous movement proved pivotal and resulted in the liberation of some of the Kashmiri areas now known as AJ & K and Gilgit- Baltistan.

            India was baffled by the Pakistan’s initiative as it was not expecting such a firm and action-oriented response from the infant state on Kashmir. The interesting fact that many people do not know is that it was not Pakistan that approached the United Nations for resolving the Kashmir dispute through a plebiscite. It was infact, India who was surprised and afraid of losing the control of the valley by calculating / assessing the progress of the Pakistani tribes men and Kashmir's in a bid to free Kashmir of her subjugation, so she went running to the UN Security Council and called for help.

            On April 21, 1948 after the first Kashmir war’s ceasefire, the UN Security Council passed its famous resolution No. 47 in its 286th meeting under the subject “The India Pakistan Question.” The result of which was “adopted” under chapter IV of the UN charter. One cannot ignore the Indian stubbornness, guile and mischief on Kashmir as today they  deny their own demand made in 1948 to the UN, which was to resolve the Kashmir issue through a UN monitored plebiscite for the Kashmiri People. After the resolution was passed in 1948 on Kashmir, over the next few years the UN Security Council passed four new resolutions, reversing the terms of Resolution 47 to include a synchronous withdrawal of both Indian and Pakistani troops from the region on recommendations of Gen Andrew Mc Naughton. To this end the UN arbitrators put forward 11 different proposals for the demilitarization of the Kashmiri region, all of which were accepted by Pakistan but rejected by the Indian government. No matter how hard India tries to show a shinning face to the world the moment Kashmir issue is raised her reality is exposed.

Countering Indian Propaganda against ISI

 by Sajjad Shaukat  
            Indian spin doctors, especially those associated with Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and other extremist Hindu groups continuously propagate against Pakistan, and aggressively use anti- ISI narrative with a view to showing Islamabad in bad light, while maligning Pakistan’s top intelligence agency, ISI. Their sick mind and elusive psyche spread intriguing thoughts and breed wickedness against country’s superior agency. Driven by their crookedness and sense of acrimony, they coin fresh jargons and initiate chimera to conduct incessant psychological operations which are detrimental to Pakistan’s interest and cause aspersions against ISI.
   
         In July 2013, Indian media, fed by its Intelligence Bureau (IB), shamelessly insinuated against ISI for reactivating its terrorist network to attack Hindu leaders and their establishments in several cities in India. Indian government was warned to put the security mechanism on high alert as RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat was touring multiple Indian states. Ultimately, the entire storyline-plot proved fake and fabricated. Pakistan ignored the Indian malevolence, suggesting that such baseless allegations will jeopardize the peace process between the two countries. But, Indian propagandists learnt nothing and ignored Pakistani advice.

           In this context, Indian newspaper Deccan Chronicle published a similar story on November 7, 2014, titled “Pakistan’s ISI may target India’s key economic centers and important installations.” In this regard, Namrata Biji Ahuja who wrote it, contended that IB and other Indian assets informed that new terror module trained by ISI have entered India to strike at key economic installations including Reserve Bank, Bombay Stock Exchange, New Delhi’s Tihar Jail, Bengaluru BSF HQ at Jalandhar, Patiala Jail in Punjab and Avantipura in J&K. IB shared information with Indian law-enforcing agencies that the group entered India via Rajasthan border and proceeded towards Pune and that they will be provided with arms and ammunition by local sleeper cells. Such media reports not only leveled serious allegations against Pakistan and ISI for training terror modules to attack Indian targets, but also inflicted serious damage to the image of Pakistan and prestige of ISI. Above all, the storyline contains biased figments of mental illusions and fake contents.
  
          Indian patterns of propaganda pose a very gruesome picture as whenever a sabotage activity is planned by Indian RAW, Indian media pro-actively accuses Pakistan for an impending terrorist attack which is straight away categorized “I labeled it as Pakistan ISI sponsored.” The possibility of RAW undertaking a dangerous terrorist activity inside their own country cannot be ruled out, as they have been doing the same in the past. In this respect, it is notable that Indian rulers were emphatically accusing Pakistan’s ISI and Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) for the Mumbai terror attacks of November 26, 2008. But, on July 19, 2013 the Indian former home ministry and ex-investigating officer Satish Verma disclosed that terror-attacks in Mumbai in November 26, 2008 and assault on Indian Parliament in January 12, 2001 were carried out by the Indian government to strengthen anti-terrorism laws.

           Similarly, exposing the nexus between Bhartia Janta Party (BJP) and RSS, Indian Home Minister Sushil Kumar Shinde revealed on January 20, 2013 that organized training camps run by the fundamentalist parties, RSS and BJP were promoting Hindu Terrorism. He also explained that these extremist parties were behind the Samjhauta Express, Meccca Masjid and Malegaon blasts.

           But, India always accused Pakistan’s ISI of all these subversive acts, while, Indian official confession shows that these terror attacks were, in fact, arranged by RAW in connivance with Indian home-grown terrorists. This could also be judged from the incident, when on April 6, 2008 in the house of Bajrang Dal fundamentalists in Nanded, a bomb went off. The investigation proved that these militants were found in the bomb-making and attack on a mosque in Parbhani in 2003. Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS) of the Maharashtra arrested a serving Lt. Col. Srikant Purohit along with other army officials, indicating that they were helping in training the Hindu terrorists, providing them with the military-grade explosive RDX, used in the Malegaon bombings and terrorist attacks in other Indian cities. ATS further disclosed that Lt. Col. Purohit confessed that in 2007, he was involved in bombing of Samjhota express, which brunt alive 70 Pakistanis.

           While, Afghanistan has become a hub of anti-Pakistan activities conducted by RAW with the tactical assistance of American CIA and Israeli Mossad—from where particularly RAW is sending logistic support to Baloch separatist elements to dismember Pakistan. For this sinister move, a religious Madrassa of Wakhan, located in Afghanistan is functioning under the patronage of RAW. It is being used for brainwashing of very young boys who are Afghans and so-called Indian Muslims. Posing themselves as Pakistani Taliban, they have joined the ranks and files of the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), and other banned extremist outfits. In the recent years, especially TTP’s insurgents and its affiliated banned groups conducted many terror-activities like suicide attacks, ruthless beheadings of tribesmen, assaults on security personnel and prominent figures including Shias, Ahmadis, Sufis, Christians, Sikhs and the suicide attack at Wagah border checkpoint in Lahore, on November 2, 2014. Besides, terror-attacks in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, FATA, Balochistan and Karachi are part of the scheme to create chaotic situation in the country. Indian Consulates in Afghanistan are also playing a very negative role in supporting TTP and Baloch separatists. Besides India is also encouraging TTP factions showing allegiance for DAISH ISIS(Islamic State in Iraq and Syria), to get united.
         
   As regards cross-border terrorism, former Indian Army Chief Gen. VK Singh openly confessed in September 2013 that special intelligence unit like Technical Services Division were raised by him to operate inside Pakistan, particularly in Balochistan and Azad Kashmir to conduct terrorism and to bribe the politicians in the Indian-occupied Kashmir.
        
    Moreover, in July 2012, Pakistani government released Indian prisoner, Surjeet Singh as part of prisoners’ exchange between the two countries. But, he openly admitted that he was in Pakistan to spy when he was arrested in 1982. In this context, Surjeet Singh said, “I was a RAW agent.” About another Indian prisoner, he revealed, “Sarabjit Singh is a terrorist who was responsible for the string of blasts in Faisalabad, Lahore and Multan in 1990.”
           
Nevertheless, as military operation, Zarb-e-Azb against terrorists is proceeding well in North Waziristan Agency by obtaining its objectives, and India feels out of sort. In this connection, Indian hawks have planned to keep Pakistan, its Armed Forces and ISI under pressure. Therefore, anti-ISI articles by their writers, associated with media wing of RAW clearly indicate Indian animosity against Pakistan and this top agency.

Nonetheless, Indian recent accusations that ISI trained modules are entering India through Rajasthan and are proceeding towards Pune are ridiculous and baseless. Hence, Pakistan must take such allegations seriously and an assertive rejoinder be issued against such media reports. While, countering Indian propaganda against ISI, our media must contest that Pakistan is a peace loving country and does not tolerate such insinuations. Indian media must owe an apology for publishing such a defamatory article in its national newspaper.

The Line of Control

Muhammad Faraz
            The animosity of fighting neighbors in the sub-continent is neither new nor surprising for the world. From super powers-to the most deprived nations of the world are aware of the bone of contention between India and Pakistan.
         
   The conflict started on division of India under the British rule in 1947, when the princely State of Kashmir was maliciously annexed to India against the popular wishes of its people who wanted to go with Pakistan. Since then India has used tremendous military might to hold on the disputed state and curb the right of self determination of the Kashmiris which is rightfully acknowledged by the United Nations. 
        
    The term Line of Control (LoC) refers to the military control line between Indian and Pakistani - control parts of the former princely state of Jammu and Kashmir. It is also known as, Asia’s “Berlin Wall”. The LoC, to this day does not constitute a legally recognized international boundary but is the de facto border. Originally known as “Cease - fire Line”, it was redesignated as the “Line of Control” after the Simla Agreement which was signed on 3rd July 1972 between India and Pakistan. The part of Kashmir controlled by India is known as Indian Occupied Kashmir (10K) and two parts of the former princely state under Pakistani control are known as Gilgit Baltistan (G8) and Azad Jammu & Kashmir (AJK).
        
    All the Indian efforts through its 700,000 military troops stationed in the valley to subjugate the right of self determination of the Kashmiris, atrocities on them, her influence in the comity of nations and defiance of UN resolutions on Kashmir, have failed miserably to end the Kashmiri freedom struggle. Kashmir was, it is and will always be an international dispute between India and Pakistan and can never be resolved through brute force. Pakistan and India had their first war in 1948 which is also known as the “first Kashmir war”. This war resulted in freedom of the areas now known as Giligit Baltistan and Azad Jammu & Kashmir, but the major areas of the valley are still occupied by the aggressive India.  The international border between India and Pakistan has seen three full scale wars (1965, 1971 and the Kargil war), including numerous short scale campaigns initiated by India whenever she got frustrated by the never ending struggle of the Kashmiris or Pakistan’s diplomatic and morale support to them.
       
     Since 1947 India has violated the LoC many a times to inflict heavy damage on the innocent Pakistani civilians in terms of loss of property and valuable human lives. In addition, it has also planted number of land mines alongside the Line of Control which has killed scores of innocent people and has left thousands as disabled. Without compensation these disabled people in Indian Kashmir are fighting hard for their survival. Not only this, at times the Hindu extremist groups like BJP blocked the Srinagar Jammu National Highway (NH1A) which is the only route that connects the Kashmir valley to rest of India. These constant torture techniques inflicted by the Indian government on the local Muslim population is enough proof of Indian brutality and stubborn approach to deny the Kashmiris their right of self determination / freedom which IS their birth right.
      
      Most recently, India has started a terrorism campaign through its Border Security Force (BSF) on the LoC which is unprecedented and lethal. Since the 2003’s ceasefire agreement, these new terror attacks on Pakistani villages along the LoC by the BSF have broken all brutality and injustice records in the history of Indo-Pak border conflicts. The Indians used heavy mortars and artillery guns not only to target Pakistani forces and their posts but deliberately and especially / specifically targeted  Pakistani villages to strike terror 1n the hearts of innocent and unarmed civilians. 
       
     The lethal use of brute Indian force did not even stop on the festival of Eid-ul-Azha, rather the Indian .forces planned and coordinated most lethal attacks on the religious festival by targeting the civilian population which resulted in the killing of dozens of innocent children, women, and others. The collateral also included killing of the live stock, destruction of houses, mosques, hospitals and schools in the Pakistani villages along the LoC.
       
     When Pakistan raised voice on the havoc played by Indian forces in the United Nations Security Council, the Indian Foreign Office without any compelling evidence started a vilification campaign, against Pakistan on different international forums of being the aggressor. 
Pakistan’s good intentions were made public when its government arranged a tour of the UN observers to the LoC in a bid to reveal the true Indian face, however, the same was denied by India on the other side and UN observers were not allowed to visit the boundary. 
         
   International community must take notice of the atrocities and brutality carried out by Indian forces on the LoC and stop India from its terror campaign on the most volatile border of the world.

LoC Violations by Indian Troops

Mohammad Jamil
           Since Narendra Modi has taken oath as Prime Minister of Indian violations at the Line of Control have increased manifold.  Only in the first five days of this week at least 13 Pakistani civilians have been killed and many injured when Indian troops resorted to un-provoked firing on the Line of Control.  It appears that Indian prime minister has deliberately created this  situation, as he wants to take advantage of Pakistan’s international crisis and also to divert attention of military from ongoing operation in NWA. Yet, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi cautioned Pakistan on Thursday that “times had changed and ceasefire violations would no be tolerated”.  Defence Minister Arun Jaitley reportedly said “If Pakistan persists with this adventurism, our forces will make cost of this  adventurism unaffordable for it”.
          From cancellation of secretary level talks to the ceasefire violations.  Pakistan’s response has been found wanting.  Addressing UNGA, Pakistan’s permanent  representative at the UN Masood Khan said: “We call upon the Indian government to immediately cease fire and help us preserve tranquility” which is too soft a statement.  However, PM Nawaz Sharif has convened the meeting of National Security council, which will be attended by top civil and military leadership.  It is hoped that the council would give Indian a message loud and clear that Pakistan will give a befitting reply if violations are not stopped.  There is perception that Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s speech in the United Nations General Assembly stating that the core issue of Jammu and Kashmir has to be resolved through negotiations in accordance with the wishes of its people could not be digested by the Indian government.
          On 1st August 2014 the every first day of assumption of this office. The Indian Army chief General Dalbir Singh Suhag referred to alleged beheading of an Indian soldier by Pakistani soldiers along the Line of Control in Poonch  Sector 18 months ago.  To a question her remarked that the said actions would get an “intense and immediate response.  A press reporter was prompted to ask question about Indian’s response to Pakistan over Indian soldier’s  beheading and mutilating his body on 8th January 2013, so that Indian army chief could spew venom against Pakistan.  Since he could not find any other reason to malign Pakistan, he found it convenient to refer to the incident that allegedly took place 18 months ago.  The Indian Army had claimed in January last year that firing by Pakistani troops near the LoC had killed two Indian soldiers with one’s head allegedly served and taken away.
          IN August 2014, Indian BSF personnel had resorted to unprovoked firing in Chaparial and Harpal sectors on the working boundary near Sialkot, which resulted in the death of two civilians a woman and a 60 year old man Pakistan also claimed that India had been using “propaganda” to divert attention from a deadly raid it had conducted  on a military post leaving a Pakistani soldier dead and another injured.  However, the continued violations of  ceasefire on LoC by the Indian Army and offensive overtures made by overzealous media and government officials are deplorable.  Over more than a decade, Pakistan’s civil and  military leaderships have shown re-straint in the wake of provocative statements by Indian civil and military leaders.  India has always baulked  at the negotiations to resolve the disputes between the two countries in including the core issue of Kashmir.
          Indian political and military leadership resorted to jingoism and continued hurling threats. It is a matter of record that Pakistan has been talking peace while Indian leaders continue to stir tension one way or another.  Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has many a time expressed his wish to have cordial relations with India and is eager to settle all the disputes with India including Kashmir through dialogue of course, pre-election Indo-Pak tension had been stirred by BJP and  other Hindu extremist organizations and the campaign was led by Narendra Modi himself.  After having being elected as Prime Minster of India he  wished to appease those who had voted for him.  Anyhow, anti Pakistan statements with provocative themes and jargons  by Indian civil and military leadership are unwarranted especially when Prim Minister Nawaz Sharif has gone extra mile to have good relations with India.
          India wanted to show to the world that the government of Pakistan and Pakistani Army were not on the same page and that Pakistan Army had killed 5 Indian soldiers to dissuade Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif from pursuing peaceful agenda with India.  By unleashing propaganda against Pakistan military.  India wants to prove that Pakistan military is against peace initiative with India.  It goes with out saying that India’s Jingoistic media follows the Indian government in fanning outage.  On the other hand  a section of Pakistan media was  often supportive of Indian narrative and Indian’s stance and insinuates that Pakistan military is  responsible for ceasefire violations because it  wants to sabotage peace imitative from Nawaz Sharif.  Some analysts see violations by India to win upcoming elections in Jammu and Kashmir.  They do not understand that BJP or Congress or their affiliates would have clear majority in Jammu and Laddakh, which is a  small  part of the Kashmir.
          In the valley, Hurriyat conference is likely to boycott the elections as usual, but even National Congress and other pro-India in the valley would not allow Modi government to withdraw Article 370 to deprive India of special status.  Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Umar Abdullah has already rejected the plan.  In a tweet , while responding to BJP leader’s statement about reviewing the above article stated: “Mark my words and save this tweet long after Modi government is a  distant memory, either J&K won’t be part of Indian or Art 370 will still exist.  “In fact this Article was the result of an agreement between Sheikh Abdullah and Jawaharlal Nehru and National Conference would considered it as violation of the  agreement.  However, it would be too simplistic to consider aggressive posture as mere LoC ceasefire violations.  Even section of Indian media stated during elections that the Hindutva candidate.  Narendra Modi was confident of his victory, adding “Modi is a religious fanatic and he wants to create a Hindu Rashtra based nation”.

Army Chief’s Loud and Clear Message

Mohammad Jamil
          Some sister game is being played in the region India is perpetually violating the ceasefire on the Line of control and  working boundary and has adopted a threatening posture through irresponsible statements by its civil and  military leadership India is also trying to create bad blood between Pakistan and brotherly country Iran.  However, Army Chief General Raheel Sharif, addressing the cadets at passing out parade at Pakistan Military Academy, vowed to thwart any aggression against the country.  He did not mince words when he said that lasting peace in the region hinges on solution on Kashmir problem in accordance with the wishes of Kashmiri people as enshrined in the UN resolutions.  He added Pakistan Army was fully capable of deterring and defeating aggression across the entire spectrum of threats.  The message is loud and clear to those harboring ill-intentions about Pakistan.
          Referring to Afghanistan General Raheel expressed the hope that the new political dispensation in Afghanistan would bring peace stability and prosperity to the people of Afghanistan and the region at large.  He assured that Pakistan Army in its capacity will do all that is necessary to support the Afghan security forces in every possible manner in fact, Pakistan had helped Afghanistan when occupied by former Soviet forces, and accommodated more than three million refugees for decades.  Yet India has been allowed to use Afghan soil to conduct clandestine activities through its proxies in Balochistan.  Yet Indian civilian and military leadership has been crying hoarse that Pakistan is supporting non-state actors in terrorists’ activities in India. On his first day in office on Ist August 2014, Indian Army chief General Dalbir Singh Suhag had warned Pakistan that India’s response to any beheading like incident in the future would be more than adequate, intense and immediate.
          It appeared that a press reporter was prompted to as question about Indian’s response to Pakistan over Indian soldier’s beheading and mutilating his body so that Indian army chief could spew venom against Pakistan.  A former army chief General Bikram Singh had stated that Indian had given a befitting reply to Pakistan after the after the incident.  One would not know as to why Dilbir Singh chose to refer to that matter after more than 18 months to lambaste Pakistan.  Indian continues with its sinister de-signs against Pakistan.  However, the continued violations of ceasefire on LoC by the Indian Army and offensive overtures made by over-zealous media and government officials are deplorable.  Over more than a decade, Pakistan’s civil and military leaderships have shown restraint in the wake of provocative statements by Indian civil and military leaders.
          Indian has always balked at the negotiations to resolve that disputes between the two countries including the core issue of Kashmir.  Indian political and military leadership resorted to jingoism and continued hurling threats.  It is a matter of record that Pakistan has been talking peace while Indian leaders continue to stir tension one way or another.  Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has many a time expressed his wish to have cordial relations with India and is eager to settle all the disputes with Indian including Kashmir through dialogue.  Of course, pre-election Indo-Pak tension had been stirred by India to influence voters to cast their votes for those political parties which abhor Pakistan and its military. According to reports, India will float a company to develop Iran’s Chabahar Port, as New Delhi aims to take advantage of thaw in Tehran’s relations with world powers.
          The port of Chabahar in south east Iran is central to India’s efforts to circumvent Pakistan and open up a route to landlocked Afghanistan were it has developed close security ties and economic interests Pakistan’s foreign office ledged a  strong protest with Iran on Saturday after the neighbouring country’s border guards stormed into Pakistani territory and killed a security official Iranian Ambassador to Pakistan Ali Raz Haghighian was summoned to the foreign Office in Islamabad, diplomatic source said and Pakistan lodged a strong protest with him over the recent incident.  Diplomatic source confirmed that during the meeting the foreign Office de-managed the Iranian ambassador to conduct a thorough investigation into the incident, which also resulted in injuries to four other Pakistanis.  The protest came hours after Iranian forces again fired mortar shells into Pakistani territory earlier on Saturday.
          According to Pakistan security officials, Iranian border guards fired three mortar shells in Mashkail, a Pakistani town bordering Iran.  The Balochistan government demanded that that the centre takes up the issue of continued border violations by Iranian border guards with the Iranian foreign office Last Friday morning Iranian border guards attacked a vehicle of Frontier Corps inside Pakistani territory killing one FC man and injuring three others.  Iranian border guards have been violating Pakistani territory for the last few days.  In another incident, at least 30 Iranian border guards entered into Pakistan’s town of Nokundi, which border Iran and made the residents of a nearby village hostage for six hours.  The FC strongly condemned the infiltration of Iranian guards and vowed to defend the border in the case of future violation of the porous 900 km border between the two countries.
          The Iranian government has been carrying out a hot pursuit of the militants and its guards often infiltrate in Pakistan.  But this does not provide an excuse to the Iranian guards to violate or undermine sovereignty of the Pakistani border the two countries share.  Thus Pakistan has every right to tell Iranians not to escalate tension on the border, as it would be considered as help to India when India is involved in violations on the Line of control and working boundary.  Pakistan and Iran are bound together by faith, common heritage and shared values of love and peace.  Both countries have co-operated and stood by each other in the event of a calamity or crisis in the past.  Though there has been a brief period of tension between two friendly countries after the revolution in Iran because of misunderstandings.  Pakistan could never think of becoming part of any intrigue to destabilize Iran.  It is a matter of record that Pakistan always supported Iran on its right to develop nuclear technology for peaceful purposes.

Kashmir under international focus

Iqbal Khan
          India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi is essentially a man in hurry, so far his foreign policy achievements have been poor; now intoxicated by the contents of joint statement of his meeting with President Obama he has jumped into another fray— fire power demonstration on the Line of Control in Kashmir and the working boundary. Interestingly, two US Senators, Timothy Kaine and King, currently visiting India have aptly suggested that the United Nations could play a bigger role in the current tensions between India and Pakistan. “I welcome the comments of the UN Secretary General calling for diplomatic efforts and dialogue to end the conflict between India and Pakistan,” King said. Kaine went a step further and said: “As a promoter of peaceful resolution of disputes, the UN does a good job and in that sense their participation should be welcomed.” These comments are pertinent as indeed significant because there are at least 20 UN resolutions on Kashmir.
          Ongoing Indian provocation seems to be in reaction to forceful projection of the cause of Kashmiri people by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif during his speech to the UN General Assembly. Ongoing Indian violence along the working boundary is well understood in the context that, historically, India resorts to such pressure tactics whenever Pakistan raises Kashmir Issue at any international forum. Adviser to the Prime Minister on National Security and Foreign Affairs, Mr Sartaj Aziz, has addressed a letter to UNSG Mr. Ban Ki-moon, on October 11 regarding the current situation of Kashmir dispute. Excerpts: “Excellency,I write to bring to your urgent attention the deteriorating security situation along the Line of Control in Jammu and Kashmir, as well as along the working boundary between Pakistan and India, owing to deliberate and unprovoked violations of the ceasefire agreement and cross-border firing by the Indian forces over the past weeks….in his meeting with you last month, the Prime Minister [of Pakistan] had underlined the need to implement UNSC resolutions on Jammu and Kashmir…Unfortunately, India has adopted a policy that runs counter to its stated desire to engage in a serious bilateral dialogue with Pakistan…During the period 1-10 October, 2014, 20 ceasefire violations along the Line of Control and 22 violations along the Working Boundary were reported, resulting in 12 civilian casualties, 52 injured civilians and 9 injured military personnel on the Pakistani side…In all, during 2014, 174 ceasefire violations along the Line of Control and 60 along the Working Boundary have been reported…Pakistan has exercised utmost restraint and responsibility in responding to these provocations….Pakistan appreciates your statement of 9 October in which you expressed concern about the recent escalation of violence along the Line of Control between India and Pakistan…Your statement is timely and significant given the historic role and responsibility of the UN towards the situation in Jammu and Kashmir, where the United Nations Military Observer Group in India and Pakistan (UNMOGIP) also continues to carry out its mandate related to the strict observance of the ceasefire. Incidentally, as I write, UNMOGIP personnel are being escorted to areas along the Line of Control, to observe first-hand the ongoing ceasefire violations by the Indian side…Pakistan believes that the United Nations has an important role to play in promoting this objective, including through your good offices…and the crucial role of the UNMOGIP on ground, which needs to be strengthened…I would also be grateful if you could have this letter circulated as an official document of the Security Council”. Historically, India and Pakistan have a poor track record of resolving any significant issue bilaterally. Pakistan should continue to build on Adviser’s letter and ask the UN for resumption of its rightful role, by tabling a UNSC resolution under Chapter 7 of the UN Charter. Last week, while chairing National Security Committee (NSC) meeting to review the situation in Kashmir, Nawaz Sharif said Pakistan’s desire for peace should not be misunderstood and called upon India to immediately honour the sanctity of the Line of Control (LoC) and working boundary and halt firing. Earlier, Pakistan’s Defence Minister told India to demonstrate caution and behave with responsibility. He reminded New Dehli that Pakistan is capable of responding befittingly to Indian actions.
          DG Rangers Punjab, in a recent briefing to media at the working boundary, said that India is not just violating ceasefire but is fighting a “small-scale war” with Pakistan. He informed that between 2010 and 2014, Indian Border Security Force has used 3.48 million small firearms on the working boundary, and more than 30,000 mortar shells have also been fired. As firing began on the first day of Eidul Azha, thousands of shells have landed in Pakistan. On October 6 alone, over 51,000 small arms were fired across the boundary, while on October 7, more than 4,000 mortar shells were fired. Exceeding the previous number, India fired over 6,000 mortar shells on October 8. The ceasefire that was agreed 10 years ago has been broken so frequently that its existence has become irrelevant. Over 35 civilians have died and thousands have fled their homes in the disputed region of Kashmir. Escalation is a reflection of the current state of bilateral ties. This fragility stems from the recent breakdown of Foreign Secretary level talks between the two countries. These talks were arbitrarily and abruptly called off by India on the pretext that Pakistan’s High Commissioner to India wanted to have a preparatory meeting with the political leadership of Indian occupied Jammu and Kashmir. Such meetings are a usual practice for the last two decades or so. During his last visit to Indian held Kashmir on India’s Independence Day, Narendra Modi adopted an aggressive tone that had fuelled war hysteria against Pakistan. Modi rode a wave of rhetoric into office that promises a tough stance on Pakistan. With an election coming up in Jammu and Kashmir, perhaps instances which substantiate the BJP’s hawkish claims may fetch it more seats. Modi’s rattling is aimed more at audiences back home:“Today, when bullets are being fired on the border, it is the enemy that is screaming…The enemy has realized that times have changed and their old habits will not be tolerated.”
          Indian Defence Minister Arun Jaitley reinforced the hawkish narrative. “If Pakistan persists with this adventurism, our forces will make cost of this adventurism unaffordable for it.” Jaitley was also quoted as ruling out talks with Pakistan. IHK Chief Minister Omar Abdullah differed with Indian defence minister’s decision of not holding any flag meetings between the two militaries during the current upsurge. “The government says there won’t be any talks until Pakistan stops firing completely. It is precisely when the firing is on that we need to talk when the guns go silent.” UN SG has expressed his concern over the recent border clashes. “Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon is concerned about the recent escalation of violence along the Line of Control between Pakistan and India,” said Ban’s spokesperson in a statement. America has also urged Pakistan and India to resume the dialogue process; US State Department spokesperson Jen Psaki said, “US diplomats are in touch with both governments to resolve their issues diplomatically and through discussions”.Though the potential for any such conflict to spiral out of control is low, it could lead to dangerous levels of escalation. It is in the interest of both India and Pakistan to control the border incidents. If the matter is left unattended, there is a likelihood of returning to pre 2003 era when heavy guns boomed on both sides on almost daily basis.